April 26, 2023
Q1/2023 stainless steel trends: Nickel and molybdenum prices fluctuate, stable/declining energy costs, road freight stable, declining sea freight rates. Strong European demand, available capacities, but Indian competition challenges local mills. What does this mean for the industry? Let's explore further.
Nickel had a rather tough start into 2023. Ending the year 2022 with around 30.000 $/to. on LME, this level has only been held until end of February 2023 from when on the value for Nickel on LME decreased by around 8.000 $/to. within 1 ½ months. As of today, Mid-April Nickel seems to be stabilizing and increasing again heading for 24.000 $/to. The forecast for Nickel is moving slightly upwards and we expect prices moving in the direction of 27.000 $/to.
Molybdenum
What is happening with the price of Molybdenum? At the end of 2022 this material closed at around 64.000 $/to. at a comparatively high level. Mills have been warned and came up with increasing prices from 2023. But the development got even crazier with Molybdenum increasing up to 105.000 $/to. peak in the beginning of February. A reason for this could be seen in the strikes in Peru, one of the biggest producers for Ferro-Molybdenum and the higher demand from China as they’re starting to produce higher quality grades more and more. Of course, all prices for Moly-grades have been under big upward pressure or have even been stopped to be offered. Now, Mid-April, Molybdenum is coming back to a more normal level around 44.500 $/to. We expect the prices to remain stable and normalize at the price-level that we’ve been used to before within the range of
40.000 – 45.000 $/to.
Chromium
Chromium have been unchanged from Q4/2022 to Q1/2023 – staying at 1,49 $/lb. The price-negotiation for Q2/2023 then came with an increase to 1,72 $/lb. due to the remaining high uncertainty on the supply from South-Africa and the increasing demand from China. Where the prices will move for Q3/2023 is very difficult to predict, especially with the current demand situation in the market.
Energy-prices
Both energy-supply and -prices are less of an issue at the moment. Natural gas comes to the same price-level as of August 2021 with around 44,00 €/Mwh. Back then, in September 2021 the first mills in Europe started to impose an energy-surcharge – so comparing the situation from today and from 1 ½ year ago of course many things have changed due to the war in the Ukraine. But still it’s interesting to see how the prices for energy have developed and are now in some areas lower compared to prewar level. We need to stay cautious, especially when we’re entering the colder periods of the year again from autumn 2023. For the coming months we expect the energy prices to remain on the same level or even decrease further.
Nearing the bottom? Freight rates have been in decline for more than a year now, and it’s clearly reasonable to ask whether the bottom is about to be reached.
The CCFI index shows that we probably haven’t reached the bottom yet. In the recent spike it reached index 3565 ultimo JAN-22 and in the first week of APR-23 it had declined to index 953 whereas the first week of APR-19 (pre pandemic) it was just below index 800 indicating there’s room for further downward development in the rates.
The situation is stable and we’re not facing any significant challenges only thing was the strike in Finland where all harbors was closed for almost two weeks in FEB-23, but with good help and a flexible partner we managed without any significant delays.
In the Central European market, the freight, both prices and availability are rather stable – probably due to slightly lower demand and traffic in general. But we need to stay very cautious, as there is still a big lack of drivers and trained personnel.
In general, the year 2023 started up better than expected talking about the demands. The whole industry has expected a slow start in 2023 with recessive developments in the biggest economies such as Germany and France. The picture we could see in the first three months now is a different one. Demands are good, at least in the range of stockholders – from the short delivery-times from the mills we can see that there are still some free capacities and lacking demand.
The picture in bar-business differs a lot in terms of origin. Looking into the European origin, the delivery-times are rather short and the willingness to negotiate base-prices came back for the first time since the Covid 19 pandemic, meaning that there are some free capacities. What causes some trouble for the European mills is the tough competition from India – here we also see shorter delivery-times than usual, and we see rather low prices compared to Europe. This makes it really hard to compare those two products with each other. The alloy-surcharge in Europe is higher than the effective price from India in some areas. For the Safeguard-quota opening 1st of April 2023 we have again seen the capacity vanish within one day, meaning the importers have had a big number of containers already waiting in the ports.
We don’t experience any challenges on the supply side as many of our mills have free capacity. Our sourcing is mainly focused on EU origin due to the missing price advantage from Asia. Price levels have been decreasing and still are. Effective prices are almost at the level of the alloy-surcharge which for sure can’t continue and if it does, we’re pretty sure that the mills will shut down parts of their production to minimize their costs/loss.
Very short delivery time, down to two weeks on commodities (OD up to 273mm) from EU and prices are at a critical level seen from a production point of view. We have not yet seen the turn in the decreasing tendency.
On the seamless tubes we still see long delivery-times and rather stable base-prices. Still Ukraine producers are running well and without big disturbances. What we also can see is the material from India pushing into Europe becomes more – following the Safeguard-quotas. But here also prices are key as the Alloy-surcharge in Europe and the higher energy-costs are having an impact on the competition between the two different origins.
The situation regarding fittings & flanges differs a lot depending on which product you’re looking at. We have welded fittings which are rather stable in terms of price and availability, while flanges from Asia are volatile in prices. Especially looking at the competition between China and India one could really experience different approaches and developments in the strategy and pricing. While China is cheaper one month, India is very aggressive the next month.
End of week 15 we’ve received the final decision from the European Commission on the anti-dumping duties on imports of stainless steel tube and pipe butt-welding fittings from China, Taiwan and Malaysia. The Commission started this investigation mid last year and now concluded that except three in the investigation named companies all other will have an anti-dumping duty of 64,9%. This means that butt-weld fittings from Asia will be less competitive compared to the European origin and the sourcing of these products from Asia will become more difficult. We’ll work our way through this and find good partners to team up with for these products in the future.
Conclusion and outlook
Our supply situation is very stable in all product groups, and we expect this to continue in the coming quarter where we are experiencing several segments with good growth. The biggest uncertainty we are experiencing at the moment is the price development, which is no longer linked to raw material prices but is largely only governed by supply and demand. If the prices do not turn around soon, we could well be hit by a more unstable supply chain, as some mills will probably shut down some of their production. In addition, there is the whole uncertainty surrounding China/Taiwan which we are following very closely as this could also affect our supply chain.